Disney World's Cars-Themed Expansion Faces Minor Roadblock with SFWMD Permit Request

Sep 16, 2024 in "Cars Land Magic Kingdom"

Frontierland Concept Art Aerial View
Posted: Monday September 16, 2024 11:00am ET by WDWMAGIC Staff

Walt Disney Imagineering's plans to transform Tom Sawyer Island and the Rivers of America at Walt Disney World's Magic Kingdom into a new Cars-themed land have hit a minor speed bump.

The South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) has returned Disney's initial permit application, requesting additional information and revisions before the project can move forward.

The permit, which focuses on modifications to the stormwater management system behind Tom Sawyer Island and Big Thunder Mountain, was a necessary early step in preparing the land for its large-scale redevelopment. Disney had filed the permit as part of its plans to ensure proper water flow and environmental considerations for the new Cars-themed area, scheduled to begin construction in 2025.

However, the SFWMD identified several inconsistencies between Disney's construction plans and the previously approved conceptual designs. These issues primarily relate to wetland impacts and how the development might affect surrounding ecosystems. The District has requested further clarification on the proposed modifications to stormwater systems, the exact extent of wetland impacts, and the mitigation measures Disney will implement to protect the environment.

In addition, the SFWMD asked Disney to revise their construction plans to include detailed maps showing the current conditions of wetlands, as well as the areas expected to be affected by the new construction. These maps must outline the full extent of wetland boundaries, upland buffers, and other water management details. The permit review also pointed out that Disney needs to ensure the project's impact on local wildlife, especially any listed species, will be minimized and appropriately mitigated.

This delay doesn't signal the end of the project but highlights the rigorous environmental regulations Disney must follow to ensure compliance with local and state requirements. The returned permit is part of the usual process for large-scale developments, especially those in environmentally sensitive areas such as wetlands.

At Horizons: Disney Experiences Showcase at D23: The Ultimate Disney Fan Event, Disney Experiences Chairman Josh D'Amaro, with the help of Tow Mater via video call, announced that a new area inspired by the Pixar Animation Studios film "Cars" will be coming to a reimagined section of Frontierland at Magic Kingdom. "The American West has always been about keeping your eyes on the horizon … believing in yourself, carving your own path, and striving toward success. That goes for miners in the mountains, bears from the country, a princess from the bayou … or a racecar from the big city," Josh told the crowd.

In this Cars adventure, guests will be able to experience two new "Cars"-themed attractions. One attraction will invite you on a thrilling rally race through the mountains. Take on wild terrain as you race across the landscape climbing mountain trails, dodging geysers and — Mater's favorite — splashing through mudholes.

The second attraction will be geared towards smaller guests and will be fun for the whole family. Work on this new space in Frontierland will begin in early 2025.

"As we develop the next generation of Disney Experiences, we're always looking for new ways to tell the stories people love," D'Amaro said. "We're thrilling Cars fans by building on this incredibly successful franchise and creating the next chapter in this story."

Discuss on the Forums

Get Walt Disney World News Delivered to Your Inbox

View all comments →

Incomudro1 hour ago

2) Is vital for me.

JackCH8 hours ago

I agree with intangible impact of aesthetics and the ROA on the experience. My question is I’m not sure if that intangible impact outweighs a lot of the benefits this area might bring. I always found myself frustrated, not peaceful, in Frontierland because of the crowd bottlenecks. This area forms a nice loop to hopefully help that. I get people find this area beautiful and charming (I do too) but I think it is a bit presumptuous to assume everyone feels that way “unconsciously” even when they consciously say they would prefer something different. I think the final verdict will ultimately depend on 1) how good the Cars E Ticket is, and 2) how good the theming is of the “natural parks” area and how much water is incorporated. I know the storytelling of the land is ruined, and that is a loss, but there is a possible net positive if what replaces it is well recieved.

John park hopper9 hours ago

RoA is classic WDW --in Bob's mind if it is not making maximum profits it has to go. Space is not a problem at WDW cars could go any where else and not impact RoA

danlb_20009 hours ago

Do these guests close their eyes when they walk through that area? If not then they are interacting with the river whether they know it or not.

lazyboy97o11 hours ago

Theme oarks are storytelling through the use of built space. The Rivers of America is the central spatial organizing element of Frontierland and Liberty Square. You can’t enter those lands and not interact with the Rivers. How things are placed is part of the experience.

Mr. Sullivan11 hours ago

How so, though? If you're a guest who already doesn't really interact with it, how is absence going to change your day?

AidenRodriguez73121 hours ago

It might have, but end of the day. I don't personally care for it. I've never interacted with it, never felt the benefits from it. If there is some invisible benefit, I am confident that that will be far outweighed by the very visible benefit fo this ride so.

Dutch Inn '761 day ago

Definitely agree. Epcot hasn't been the same since the '98-99 move away from "edutainment." Out with Imagination, World of Motion, & Horizons. It's been searching for its purpose since then, and is still floundering. Hollywood Studios is the same; out with the Animators, street performers, back lot, etc, and now it's "The Not Quite As Cool Magic Kingdom." They butchered Downtown Disney/Pleasure Island and turned it into a shopping mall. But I guess they're making money - and that's the name of the game. Animal Kingdom has never really been built out completely - I hope the planned additions don't take away from the mission/theme there too much, and finally give us a complete Park. The only place that has been constant and on point throughout, has been the Magic Kingdom. I'm afraid they're going to take away some of the appeal for me as well. I understand why they're doing it: they're taking the underperforming part of their busiest Park and attempting to bring it up to speed with the rest of the place. The positive in this is that maybe it will spread crowds out across the MK more efficiently. The negative is that they're removing my favorite part of Disney World. The fact that my favorite part is the least popular area probably means that American culture has just left me (and a lot of us) behind.

danlb_20001 day ago

I would bet it has a bigger impact on your day then you realize.

AidenRodriguez7311 day ago

As someone who never set foot and watched walkthroughs, I really honestly couldn't care less about the river. I know its a controversial opinion but its just how me and my family experience the parks. It's kinda cool to look at but the concept art, even if we don't get the full level, looks better to me. I think there's a more tasteful way of doing it to keep some water by HM or BTM though... but if not, I'm not going to sweat much.

Incomudro2 days ago

100%. And I myself have never set foot on Tom Sawyer Island.

danlb_20002 days ago

This is exactly how I feel. Even if you never set foot on Tom Sawyer's island, or ride the riverboat, that river still has an intangible impact on your park experience.

Incomudro2 days ago

Oh, that makes it ok then.:confused:

ToTBellHop2 days ago

Imagine all of Hollywood and Sunset Blvd.’s buildings being converted into gorgeous DVC studios with fold-down beds and two (2!) sinks!